The surviving records of the St. Paul's Presbyterian Church are largely in the custody of the St. Paul's United Church, but the following can be found at the conference archives of Manitoba and Northwestern Ontario: copy of a sermon given on June 28, 1903, which includes historical information; dated notes pertaining to the life of the congregation and the church building, including references to local Methodists, 1884.

The records of the Souris Pastoral charge held at the conference archives include annual reports (1947-1968).

The records of Fifth Avenue United Church held at the conference archives include: Sacramental Register pertaining to Baptisms (1914-1929), Marriages (1913-1929) and Burials (1913-1922); records of the Ladies Aid (1916-1936); financial records (1926, 1927, 1930); and records of the congregation (1882-1939).

The records of Fifth Avenue Methodist Church held at the conference archives include: records of the Trustee Board (1889-1918); financial records (1905-1918); wiring contract (1917); records of the Sunday School (1893-1914); and a Circuit Register (1882-1908).

The records of St. Paul's United Church held at the conference archives include records of the Sunday School (1900-1908) and records of the congregation (1896-1908).

The records of the Pembina Parish Pastoral charge include: a Sacramental register pertaining to communion (1917-1943); records from the congregation (1928, 1934); and annual reports (1982, 1990, 1993).

The records of St. Paul's United Church held at the conference archives include: a Sacramental Register pertaining to Baptisms (1885-1912, 1897), and Marriages (1886-1890, 1886-1911); and records of the Trustees (1888-1906, 1908-1920).

Items described here consist of: a Sacramental Register containing entries for baptisms (1925-1952); a Communion Roll (1926-1962); minutes of meetings of the Board of Management and minutes of Annual Meetings of the congregation (1925-1941); and a financial ledger (1942-1952).

Items described as part of this series include the Communion Roll for the Glenlyon Presbyterian Appointment with entries dating from 1897 to 1917. This volume also contains minutes of the meeting of the Glenlyon Presbyterian Appointment Session dating from 1917.

The records of Carman Larger Pastoral charge held at the conference archives include: records of the Official Board (1974-1997); records of the Official Board Executive (1988-1997); records of the congregation (1984-1998); records of the Finance Committee (1970-1997); financial records (1927-1962, 1985-1996); records of the Forward Planning Committee (1985-1986); records of the Christian Education Committee (1988, 1992); and records of the Mission and Service Committee (1987-1997).